Responsive Styling Using Attribute Selectors

Responsive Styling Using Attribute Selectors

At 3/31/2024

One of the challenges we face when implementing class-based atomic styling is that it often depends on a specific breakpoint for context.

<div class="span-12"></div> <!-- we want this for small screens  -->
<div class="span-6"></div>  <!-- we want this for medium screens -->
<div class="span-4"></div>  <!-- we want this for large screens  -->

It’s common to use a prefix to target each breakpoint:

<div class="sm-span-12 md-span-6 lg-span-4"></div>

This works well until we start adding multiple classes. That’s when it becomes difficult to keep a track what relates to what and where to add, remove. or change stuff.

<div class="
  sm-span-12 
  md-span-6 
  lg-span-4 
  sm-font-size-xl 
  md-font-size-xl 
  lg-font-size-xl 
  md-font-weight-500 
  lg-font-weight-700">
</div>

We can try to make it more readable by re-grouping:

<div class="
  sm-span-12 
  sm-font-size-xl 


  md-span-6 
  md-font-size-xl 
  md-font-weight-500 


  lg-span-4 
  lg-font-size-xl 
  lg-font-weight-700">
</div>

We can add funky separators (invalid class names will be ignored):

<div class="
  [
   sm-span-12 
   sm-font-size-xl 
  ],[
   md-span-6 
   md-font-size-xl 
   md-font-weight-500 
  ],[
   lg-span-4 
   lg-font-size-xl 
   lg-font-weight-700
  ]">
</div>

But this still feels messy and hard to grasp, at least to me.

We can get a better overview and avoid implementation prefixes by grouping attribute selectors instead of actual classes:

<div 
  data-sm="span-12 font-size-lg"
  data-md="span-6 font-size-xl font-weight-500"
  data-lg="span-4 font-size-xl font-weight-700"
>
</div>

These aren’t lost of classes but a whitespace-separated list of attributes we can select using [attribute~="value"], where ~= requires the exact word to be found in the attribute value in order to match.

@media (min-width: 0) {
 [data-sm~="span-1"] { /*...*/ }              
 [data-sm~="span-2"] { /*...*/ }   
 /* etc. */ 
}
@media (min-width: 30rem) {
 [data-md~="span-1"] { /*...*/ }   
 [data-md~="span-2"] { /*...*/ }   
 /* etc. */   
}
@media (min-width: 60rem) {
 [data-lg~="span-1"] { /*...*/ }   
 [data-lg~="span-2"] { /*...*/ }   
 /* etc. */   
}

It may be a bit odd-looking but I think translating atomic classes to  attributes is fairly straightforward (e.g. .sm-span-1 becomes [data-sm~="span-1"]). Plus, attribute selectors have the same specificity as classes, so we lose nothing there. And, unlike classes, attributes can be written without escaping special characters, like /+.:?.

That’s all! Again, this is merely an idea that aims to make switching declarations in media queries easier to write, read and manage. It’s definitely not a proposal to do away with classes or anything like that.

Copyrights

We respect the property rights of others and are always careful not to infringe on their rights, so authors and publishing houses have the right to demand that an article or book download link be removed from the site. If you find an article or book of yours and do not agree to the posting of a download link, or you have a suggestion or complaint, write to us through the Contact Us, or by email at: support@freewsad.com.

More About us